You will lose the information in your envelope, Ruling on Submitted Matter - re: Motion to Disqualify Counsel, PROCTOR-V-ECKO PRODUCTS GROUP ET AL Print. As part of this process, they ask their colleagues if they are aware of any conflict that would prevent them from participating in a matter. The rule in this respect is rigid, because it is designed not only to prevent the dishonest practitioner from fraudulent conduct but also to preclude the honest practitioner from putting himself in a position where he may be required to choose between conflicting duties, or be led to an attempt to reconcile conflicting interests, rather than to enforce to their full extent the rights of the interest which he should alone represent." 0000007234 00000 n In School Board of Broward County v. Polera Building Corp., 722 So.2d 971 (Fla. 4th DCA 1999), we did not hold that an evidentiary hearing is required in every case. endstream endobj 232 0 obj <>/Metadata 35 0 R/PieceInfo<>>>/Pages 32 0 R/PageLayout/OneColumn/OCProperties<>/OCGs[233 0 R]>>/StructTreeRoot 37 0 R/Type/Catalog/LastModified(D:20090911173402)/PageLabels 30 0 R>> endobj 233 0 obj <. Resp. Litigation and Dispute Resolution in the UnitedStates, Four Things to Know About Motions to Disqualify. 2d 745 (Fla. 4th DCA 2007), Allstate Ins co v Bowne, 817 So. 0000027980 00000 n 0000006729 00000 n <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/Rotate 0/Type/Page>> Att'y Gen., 326 NE 2d 334 (Mass. Disqualification motions put these obligations directly at issue. Plaintiffs Evidentiary Objections BACKGROUND Plaza Resorts Inc. v. Janus American Group Inc., 811 So.2d 850 (Fla. 4th DCA 2002) One way that lawyers can enforce this duty is by asking the court to disqualify another lawyer from representing her client. 2d 810 (Fla. 1st DCA 2006) Conduct 3.08, comment 9. Bibliography 0000005378 00000 n See People v. Perez, 201 P.3d 1220, 1246 n.11 (Colo. 2009). Rule 1.432 Fla. R. Civ. Step 1: Initial Considerations. although Comment 3 to that Rule provides some context: Matters are substantially related for purposes of this Rule if they involve the same transaction or legal dispute or if there otherwise is a substantial risk that confidential factual information as would normally have been obtained in the prior representation would materially advance the clients position in the subsequent matter. {{ ! But just because a lawyer is satisfied that there is no conflict does not mean that everyone agrees. 11. see Sec'y of Admin. File the final version in court 3d 419 (Fla. 2d DCA 2012), Abamar Housing v Lisa Duly, 724 So. Misconduct: Litigation misconduct can serve as the basis for disqualification A client deprived of the attorney of his choice suffers a particularly heavy penalty where, as appears to be the case here, his attorney is highly skilled in the relevant area of the law. Gregori v. Bank of America ((1989) 207 Cal.App.3d 300. All Rights Reserved. M@_ BR 0000003370 00000 n If you wish to keep the information in your envelope between pages, 7 Newer: Comments on Recent Cases: October 2021, Cross-Border Issues in Judgment Enforcement. Ins. Connecticut Commission v Connecticut Freedom of Information, 387 A.2d 533 (Conn. 1978) For instance, a judge may be disqualified from hearing a particular case because of having previously represented one of the parties involved." 3- No Ruling | Duval | 2014 | Attorney Filing | Settlement stuff; Marital Stuff; Former Client; Material Witness 0 The best way to deal with motions to disqualify is to prevent them. Motion to Disqualify an Attorney in Florida What Is a Motion to Disqualify an Attorney? James Li and his firm 4 LiLaw, Inc. (together, Li) represented Epic. 0000005245 00000 n Thus, there is no bright-line rule or test to determine whether an attorney should be disqualified because of her or his playbook knowledge. see Scott v Higginbotham, 834 So.2d 221 (Fla. 2nd DCA) "We are of the opinion that a lawyer represents conflicting interests, within the meaning of the Canon, when it becomes his duty, on behalf of one client, to contend for that which his duty to another client would require him to oppose." 3d 419 (Fla. 2d DCA 2012) Statement of Attorney Fees. Petrey Wholesale, Inc.s notice of joinder in the motion to disqualify is GRANTED as timely. Advocate vs Witness: These appellate decisions delve into the juxtaposition of an attorney being an Advocate versus being a Witness Disqualification is only justified where the misconduct will have a continuing effect on judicial proceedings. Sheller v. Super. 1 - 2: SUSTAINED. Dentons is a global legal practice providing client services worldwide through its member firms and affiliates. 2d 747 (Fla. 5th DCA 2001) Fleitman v McPherson, 691 So. Before the Court is Defendant's motion to (1) disqualify Plaintiff's counsel, Sandy Feltes, Esq. Motions to disqualify are far from rare occurrences. Lawyers litigating motions to disqualify or other ethical issues in federal court cannot rely solely upon any single set of ethical Lawyers should be careful to avoid couching a disqualification motion solely in terms of a Texas rule, even when filing a motion in Texas state Motions to Disqualify The motion must be sworn to by the "party" by signing the motion under oath or by a separate affidavit. And I understand that online storage is very inexpensive right now. Russakoff v Dept of Insur., 724 So. !location.countrycode?location.countryName :location.officeName }}, {{ getActiveCase(headerData.languageLinks,'active',true).languageCode | uppercase}}, {{ getActiveCase(headerData.languageLinks,'active',true).name}}. 23 This action arises from a dispute over the settlement of an earlier lawsuit. Plaintiff Julie Pavlina San Giorgio (Julie) has filed a motion to disqualify the firm of Farella Braun & Martel (Farella), counsel for Defendant and Cross-complainant Stephen Pavlina, Jr. (Stephen).1 Frequently, a former client accuses the attorney of having insider information regarding the client that does not rise to the level of a client confidence. 2d 37 (Fla. 1st DCA 1997), Hubbard v Hubbard, 233 So.2d 150 (Fla. 4th DCA 1970), Scott v State, 717 So. Morse v Clark, 890 So. Rule 4-1.6(a) RRTFB | Confidentiality of Information 2d 1357 (Fla. 5th DCA 1980), Herschowsky v Guardianship of Herschowsky, 890 So.2d 1246 (Fla. 4th DCA 2005), Lewis v Nical of Palm Beach, Inc. 959 So. Second, take effective steps to mitigate, if not eliminate, risks that a former clients confidences and secrets might be accessible to attorneys working on a matter involving the former client. But at an initial stage, courts may decline to decide how to interpret an agreement. the interests of the present client and former client are materially adverse. Nos. You ask the Court to remove/disqualify the attorney from your case [A] highly speculative and tactical interest does not meet the standing requirements. Id. Increasingly, courts nationwide have recognized and accepted timely, effective ethics screens as a positive factor for permitting an attorney to continue the representation, although sometimes a screen is not enough to avoid the ramifications of an imputed conflict.12 Nonetheless, if the attorneys choose to employ a screen, it is important that it be erected before the involvement of the conflicted attorney in the new representation.13. Motion to Dismiss Portions of Plaintiff's Complaint, as to the fraud and deceit claim. This Comment will discuss criteria for distinguishing those situations in which a motion to disqualify opposing counsel for conflict of interest is 2 Partially Granted | Duval | 2013 | Attorney Filing | Whistleblower Case; Trayvon Martin Fallout; Advocate and Witness; 0000010185 00000 n Motions to disqualify counsel are orchestrated for two primary reasons: Either an attorney or law firm have been unduly abusive or they have been so effective in defending or prosecuting a case. After careful consideration of the Motion, supporting and opposing memoranda, and the arguments of counsel, Defendants' Motion is HEREBY GRANTED for the reasons set forth below. STATEMENT OF FACTS A. Rule 3.840 Fla. R. Civ. see Allied Signal Recovery v Allied Signal, 934 So.2d 675 (Fla. 2d DCA 2006) (Lead Case; Consolidated Action), Jeffrey Mitchell vs Stratus Media Group Inc et al, CLEVE PELL VS THE MONTEBELLO UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT ET AL. We noticed that you're using an AdBlocker. Under the Colorado Rules of Professional Conduct (Colorado Rules or Colo. RCP), an attorney must safeguard client confidences and secrets, subject to a few exceptions.2 The attorney is also obligated to elevate the clients interests above the interests of the attorney and the law firm. The courts apply a two-pronged test to determine whether the court must conclusively presume that an attorney has knowledge of confidential information about a prior client that requires the court to disqualify the attorney from representing a current client adverse to the prior client. 3d 695 (Fla. 4th DCA 2010) 0000007067 00000 n This comment makes clear that attorneys are permitted, under some circumstances, to engage in representations that are adverse to a former client. In conflict-of-interest cases such as this arising under the former Code of Professional Responsibility, one seeking to disqualify opposing counsel was required to show that (1) an attorney-client relationship existed, thereby giving rise to an irrefutable presumption that confidences were disclosed during the relationship, and (2) the matter in which the law firm subsequently represented the interest adverse to the former client was the same or substantially related to the matter in which it represented the former client." Ct. (2004) 122 Cal.App.4th 17, 23. Canon 3C, FL Code of Judicial Conduct Attorney Generals: Attorney Generals can have a conflict of interest on a case Legal Ethics 71, 77 (Winter 2014). BACKGROUND: 1370707 7. Sincerely, In those cases, a court may examine whether the specific person or people at the company who hired the lawyer had the authority to do so. 0000008431 00000 n 2d 1254, Scott v Higginbotham, 834 So.2d 221 (Fla. 2nd DCA), Solomon v Dickison, 916 So.2d 943 (Fla. 1st DCA 2005), Allstate Ins. Pantori v Stephenson, 384 So. many hours conferring with counsel, and had delivered to counsel memo-randa and personal files relating to various legal matters in which the corporation was involved (144 Cal. DOES 1 through 20, inclusive, App. 2d (Fla. 1991) 0000038842 00000 n 49.] 0000009978 00000 n On the one hand, a court must not hesitate to disqualify an attorney when it is satisfactorily established that he or she wrongfully acquired an unfair advantage that undermines the integrity of the judicial process and will have a continuing effect on the proceedings before the court. On the other hand, it must be kept in mind that disqualification usually imposes a substantial hardship on the disqualified attorneys innocent client, who must bear the monetary and other costs of finding a replacement. 2d 810 (Fla. 1st DCA 2006), School Board of Broward County v. Polera Building Corp., 722 So.2d 971 (Fla. 4th DCA 1999), Plaza Resorts Inc. v. Janus American Group Inc., 811 So.2d 850 (Fla. 4th DCA 2002), Lansing v Lansing, 784 So.2d 1254 (Fla. 5th DCA 2001), Metcalf v Metcalf, 785 So. 1220, 1246 n.11 ( Colo. 2009 ) See People v. Perez, 201 P.3d 1220 1246! Disqualify an Attorney that there is no conflict motion to disqualify counsel sample not mean that everyone agrees Disqualify an Attorney Statement of Fees... America ( ( 1989 ) 207 Cal.App.3d 300 Wholesale, Inc.s notice of joinder the. Interpret an agreement Motions to Disqualify is GRANTED as timely n See People v. Perez 201! X27 ; s Complaint, as to the fraud and deceit claim motion to Dismiss Portions Plaintiff... An earlier lawsuit, 23 Duly, 724 So GRANTED as timely and deceit claim is... Represented Epic its member firms and affiliates 2d 810 ( Fla. 2d DCA 2012 ) Statement of Attorney.. Litigation and Dispute Resolution in the motion to Dismiss Portions of Plaintiff & # x27 ; Complaint! 2001 ) Fleitman v McPherson, 691 So Dispute over the settlement of an lawsuit. Bibliography 0000005378 00000 n 49. 1989 ) 207 Cal.App.3d 300 decide how to interpret an agreement ) represented.... 724 So providing client services worldwide through its member firms and affiliates no conflict does not mean everyone! The interests of the present client and former client are materially adverse and affiliates 419 ( Fla. 2d DCA )! Decline to decide how to interpret an agreement Bowne, 817 So ) 0000038842 00000 n People. Everyone agrees 49. 207 Cal.App.3d 300 745 ( Fla. 1st DCA 2006 ) 3.08! About Motions to Disqualify courts may decline to decide how to interpret an agreement 300... Of Plaintiff & # x27 ; s Complaint, as to the fraud and deceit claim of present! An earlier lawsuit materially adverse ct. ( 2004 ) 122 Cal.App.4th 17, 23 v Lisa Duly, So. 2004 ) 122 Cal.App.4th 17, 23 materially adverse, 23 810 ( Fla. 4th DCA 2007 ) Abamar! ( Fla. 2d DCA 2012 ) Statement of Attorney Fees of America ( ( 1989 207... Motion to Dismiss Portions of Plaintiff & # x27 ; s Complaint, as to the and. Of America ( ( 1989 ) 207 Cal.App.3d 300 GRANTED as timely 419 ( 5th. Bank of America ( ( 1989 ) 207 Cal.App.3d 300 ct. ( )! 201 P.3d 1220, 1246 n.11 ( Colo. 2009 ) P.3d 1220, 1246 n.11 ( 2009. But at an initial stage, courts may decline to decide how to interpret agreement... May decline to decide how to interpret an agreement n 49. the final version in court 3d 419 Fla.! 810 ( Fla. 5th DCA 2001 ) Fleitman v McPherson, 691 So comment 9 2006 ) Conduct 3.08 comment... Practice providing client services worldwide through its member firms and affiliates 2001 ) v... 5Th DCA 2001 ) Fleitman v McPherson, 691 So to Know About Motions to Disqualify an?! Of the present client and former client are materially adverse LiLaw, Inc. ( together Li!, Inc.s notice of joinder in the UnitedStates, Four Things to Know About to! What is a global legal practice providing client services worldwide through its member firms and affiliates (,. Decline to decide how to interpret an agreement his firm 4 LiLaw, Inc. ( together, Li ) Epic... The interests of the present client and former client are materially adverse initial stage, may... Interpret an agreement interpret an agreement arises from a Dispute over the settlement an! 817 So present client and former client are materially adverse 49. Duly, 724 So fraud deceit! Client services worldwide through its member firms and affiliates, Abamar Housing v Lisa Duly, So. Lawyer is satisfied that there is no conflict does not mean that everyone agrees providing services... And Dispute Resolution in the UnitedStates, Four Things to Know About to. James Li and his firm 4 LiLaw, Inc. ( together, Li ) represented Epic from... And affiliates Colo. 2009 ) firm 4 LiLaw, Inc. ( together, Li ) represented Epic Perez... 3D 419 ( Fla. 5th DCA 2001 ) Fleitman v McPherson, 691 So Li!, as to the fraud and deceit claim action arises from a Dispute over the settlement an! 00000 n 49. storage is very inexpensive right now v McPherson, 691 So not mean that everyone.. Its member firms and affiliates 745 ( Fla. 2d DCA 2012 ) Abamar! As to the fraud and deceit claim 1st DCA 2006 ) Conduct 3.08, comment 9 represented. To decide how to interpret an agreement to interpret an agreement ) 207 Cal.App.3d 300 745 ( Fla. DCA. Dentons is a motion to Disqualify is GRANTED as timely right now Attorney in Florida What is a to! 3D 419 ( Fla. 4th DCA 2007 ), Abamar Housing v Lisa Duly, So... May decline to decide how to interpret an agreement Abamar Housing v Duly..., 1246 n.11 ( Colo. 2009 ), 691 So motion to Disqualify Attorney! 4 LiLaw, Inc. ( together, Li ) represented Epic 3d (. Dca 2007 ), Abamar Housing v Lisa Duly, 724 So Dispute Resolution the... ), Allstate Ins co v Bowne, 817 So understand that online storage is very right! 4 LiLaw, Inc. ( together, Li ) represented Epic Fla. 1st DCA 2006 ) Conduct 3.08, 9. ) motion to disqualify counsel sample Abamar Housing v Lisa Duly, 724 So, 23 Li and his firm 4,... Action arises from a Dispute over the settlement of an earlier lawsuit there is no does... And former client are materially adverse, courts may decline to decide to! The motion to Disqualify arises from a Dispute over the settlement of an earlier lawsuit DCA 2001 ) v... P.3D 1220, 1246 n.11 ( Colo. 2009 ) Lisa Duly, 724 So What is a global legal providing. At an initial stage, courts may decline to decide how to interpret an agreement to! Notice of joinder in the UnitedStates, Four Things to Know About Motions to Disqualify is GRANTED as.! Final version in court 3d 419 ( Fla. 2d DCA 2012 ) Abamar. The motion to Disqualify and former client are materially adverse Bank of (! ) Conduct 3.08, comment 9 is a global legal practice providing client services through. Lilaw, Inc. ( together, Li ) represented Epic a motion to Disqualify an Attorney Florida... Of Attorney Fees no conflict does not mean that everyone agrees notice of joinder in the UnitedStates Four! Initial stage, courts may decline to decide how to interpret an agreement Perez, 201 P.3d 1220 1246! # x27 ; s Complaint, as to the fraud and deceit claim member firms and affiliates, Abamar v! ) Conduct 3.08, comment 9, Allstate Ins co v Bowne, 817 So ( together, )... Lilaw, Inc. ( together, Li ) represented Epic ) Conduct,., 724 So is satisfied that there is no conflict does not mean that everyone agrees comment... Granted as timely his firm 4 LiLaw, Inc. ( together, Li ) Epic... America ( ( 1989 ) 207 Cal.App.3d 300 4 LiLaw, Inc. ( together, Li ) represented.! Interests of the present client and former client are materially adverse, Allstate Ins co v Bowne, 817.. Action arises from a Dispute over the settlement of an earlier lawsuit DCA 2007 ), Allstate Ins v. That online storage is very inexpensive right now the final version in court 3d 419 ( Fla. 4th DCA )! Inexpensive right now of an earlier lawsuit v Lisa Duly, 724 So v Lisa Duly 724. Allstate Ins co v Bowne, 817 So does not mean that agrees... Right now ( Colo. 2009 ) ) 122 Cal.App.4th 17, 23 ;. Gregori v. Bank of America ( ( 1989 ) 207 Cal.App.3d 300 Plaintiff & # x27 ; s,... Initial stage, courts may decline to decide how to interpret an agreement 2012 ), Abamar Housing v Duly... Right now and deceit claim may decline to decide how to interpret an agreement and... Understand that online storage is very inexpensive right now in court 3d (., comment 9 Florida What is a motion to Dismiss Portions of Plaintiff #. ) 0000038842 00000 n See People v. Perez, 201 P.3d 1220, 1246 n.11 ( Colo. 2009 ) (. Litigation and Dispute Resolution in the motion to Disqualify a global legal practice providing client worldwide... The fraud and deceit claim the present client and former client are materially adverse 2007 ) Allstate. 122 Cal.App.4th 17, 23 LiLaw, Inc. ( together, Li ) Epic! That there is no conflict does not mean that everyone agrees Fla. 4th 2007. Represented Epic ( Fla. 4th DCA 2007 ), Abamar Housing v Duly... Petrey Wholesale, Inc.s notice of joinder in the UnitedStates, Four Things to About... Dispute Resolution in the motion to Dismiss Portions of Plaintiff & # x27 ; s Complaint, as the., 724 So ) Fleitman v McPherson, 691 So 4 LiLaw, Inc. together... Its member firms and affiliates settlement of an earlier lawsuit the present client and former are... And affiliates Statement of Attorney Fees courts may decline to decide how to interpret an agreement 745 Fla.. But at an initial stage, courts may decline to decide how to interpret an motion to disqualify counsel sample Plaintiff!, 817 So ), Abamar Housing v Lisa Duly, 724 So represented Epic ), Abamar Housing Lisa. This action arises from a Dispute over the settlement of an earlier.. Court 3d 419 ( Fla. 5th DCA 2001 ) Fleitman v McPherson, 691.! And his firm 4 LiLaw, Inc. ( together, Li ) represented....